The Boston Red Sox Make the Right Move: Garrett Whitlock Returns to the Bullpen.
On Saturday, Boston Red Sox pitcher Garrett Whitlock confirmed he will be working out of the bullpen for the 2025 season. This decision, announced ahead of the upcoming campaign, appears to be a smart and strategic move by the organization for several key reasons.
Prioritizing Whitlock’s Health
Whitlock is coming off Tommy John surgery, a procedure that requires meticulous management for pitchers to regain and maintain their effectiveness. While he isn’t expected to be ready for Opening Day, shifting him to the bullpen upon his return will significantly reduce his workload, allowing the team to better protect his arm in the long run. A bullpen role typically involves fewer innings pitched and less frequent extended outings, minimizing the strain on a player recovering from such a major surgery.
This move aligns with Whitlock’s history and physical limitations. Despite showing flashes of brilliance, his body has struggled to endure the demands of a starting pitcher’s workload. After an outstanding rookie season in 2021, where he pitched 46 games in relief, Whitlock’s availability has dwindled. Injuries limited him to 22 appearances in 2023 (10 of which were starts) and a mere four games in 2024. Additionally, Whitlock has never thrown more than 78.1 innings at the major-league level, reinforcing the idea that his talents are better utilized in shorter bursts.
Solid Rotation Depth
The Red Sox already boast a full rotation for 2025, leaving little room—or need—for Whitlock as a starter. With Garrett Crochet, Walker Buehler, Tanner Houck, Brayan Bello, and Kutter Crawford forming a dependable five-man rotation, there’s no urgency to force Whitlock into a role that may overextend him. Crawford’s position as the sixth starter also provides valuable depth, ensuring the rotation remains stable even in the event of injuries or underperformance.
By clearly defining Whitlock as a bullpen option, the team creates clarity and stability. This decision not only eliminates ambiguity about roles but also allows Whitlock to focus on excelling in a specialized capacity where he has already thrived.
Proven Success as a Reliever
Whitlock’s track record as a reliever speaks for itself. During his breakout 2021 campaign, he posted an impressive 1.96 ERA, becoming a crucial part of the Red Sox’s journey to the ALCS. His ability to consistently dominate in high-leverage situations made him one of the most valuable arms in the bullpen that season.
Returning to the bullpen also addresses one of the team’s weaknesses from the 2024 season. The relief corps, which faced challenges last year, is poised to become a major strength with Whitlock’s presence. He will join an already talented group that includes Liam Hendricks, Aroldis Chapman, Justin Wilson, Justin Slaten, and Josh Winckowski. With Whitlock in the mix, the bullpen gains not only depth but also a reliable weapon for late-game situations.
Looking Ahead
The decision to move Garrett Whitlock back to the bullpen is a reflection of the Red Sox’s commitment to maximizing their roster’s strengths while safeguarding a talented pitcher’s future. By managing his workload, bolstering their bullpen, and maintaining clarity within the pitching staff, Boston has set itself up for success in 2025.
Whitlock’s ability to shine in relief, coupled with the team’s existing rotation depth, makes this move a win-win. As the season progresses, his contributions could prove pivotal in the Red Sox’s quest for another postseason run.
