Alabama’s head football coach, Kalen DeBoer, faces a pivotal decision heading into the 2025 season—a decision that could define the program’s trajectory for years to come. At the heart of this choice is the quarterback situation, with Ty Simpson emerging as a strong contender to take the reins. After three years of preparation, Simpson’s experience gives him a distinct advantage over promising freshman Keelon Russell and Washington transfer Austin Mack. However, questions about his readiness and potential persist.
Simpson appears to be the frontrunner due to his familiarity with Alabama’s system and the trust he has likely built with the coaching staff during his time as a backup. Yet, his limited playing time raises concerns. Critics, such as USA Today’s Blake Toppmeyer, have questioned whether Simpson possesses the qualities of a top-tier SEC quarterback. Toppmeyer points out that Simpson’s three-year stint as a backup is unusual in today’s college football landscape, where immediate impact is often expected.
“If Simpson succeeds, his story will be one of perseverance and patience paying off,” Toppmeyer explained. “But if he falters, the scrutiny will fall squarely on DeBoer, potentially putting his job in jeopardy.” Toppmeyer also noted that Simpson’s lone start against South Florida in 2023 left much to be desired, fueling skepticism about his ability to lead the Crimson Tide effectively.
The stakes couldn’t be higher for DeBoer. The decision to start Simpson carries significant risks, particularly in a competitive SEC environment where every game matters. While some hope for a breakout season akin to Georgia’s Carson Beck, there are no guarantees. DeBoer’s coaching staff has demonstrated the ability to develop talent, but Simpson’s potential remains an open question.
Despite the risks, it would be unwise for DeBoer to sideline Simpson without giving him a fair shot. His years of preparation and investment in Alabama’s system deserve a moment to shine. If Simpson can capitalize on this opportunity, he has the chance to solidify himself as a cornerstone of the team’s success. On the other hand, if he struggles, DeBoer could face intense scrutiny from fans and analysts alike.
Ultimately, DeBoer’s decision will not only shape Alabama’s upcoming season but also serve as a reflection of his leadership and vision for the program. While the gamble on Simpson could prove costly, the reward—a stable and productive quarterback situation—may well be worth the risk. For now, the spotlight shines brightly on Tuscaloosa as the Crimson Tide prepare for what could be a defining season in their storied history.
