Boston Red Sox: Evaluating Offseason Moves and Addressing Key Needs.
The Boston Red Sox have approached the offseason with a measured strategy, making incremental additions to their roster while steering clear of the blockbuster signings seen elsewhere in Major League Baseball. Although their trade for Garrett Crochet strengthened their starting rotation, it is evident that shoring up the bullpen remains a top priority. Among the relievers Boston considered was Tanner Scott, who ultimately signed a four-year contract with the Los Angeles Dodgers.
The Red Sox and Tanner Scott: A Missed Opportunity?
Chris Cotillo of MassLive.com highlighted Boston’s interest in Scott but noted that the organization hesitated to commit to the terms of his deal. Sources indicate that the Red Sox maintained communication with Scott throughout the offseason but were reluctant to match the Dodgers’ offer. Contrary to reports suggesting Boston proposed a more lucrative package, Cotillo clarified this claim as “very inaccurate.”
The primary sticking point for Boston appeared to be the contract’s length. A four-year commitment to the 29-year-old left-handed reliever—who will be 34 by the conclusion of the deal—gave the Red Sox pause. While Scott’s skill set, particularly his ability to neutralize elite hitters like Shohei Ohtani, would have bolstered their bullpen, the Red Sox prioritized flexibility over long-term risk.
Remaining Options in the Reliever Market
Boston’s focus now shifts to other available arms in free agency. Notable names include Carlos Estévez and Kirby Yates. Estévez, a 32-year-old hard-throwing right-hander, has garnered interest from teams like the Chicago Cubs and Toronto Blue Jays, both of which were also pursuing Scott. Given his age, Estévez represents a lower long-term risk for Boston, making him a more appealing target. Meanwhile, 37-year-old veteran Kirby Yates carries more risk due to his age and potential durability concerns, but he brings a wealth of experience that could prove valuable to Boston’s bullpen.
Addressing Broader Team Needs
Improving the bullpen is only one piece of the puzzle for Boston as they look to remain competitive in the American League. The infield remains a notable area of need, and one intriguing solution could be Alex Bregman. The 29-year-old Houston Astros star would be a seamless fit, particularly given his willingness to transition to second base. His connection to Red Sox manager Alex Cora, who coached him during his time in Houston, adds another layer of plausibility to this potential move.
Bregman’s presence would solidify the infield while also injecting leadership and playoff experience into the Red Sox roster. His addition, combined with another quality reliever like Estévez or Yates, could position Boston as legitimate contenders in what is shaping up to be a wide-open American League.
Competitive Dynamics in the American League
This offseason, many of the league’s marquee talents have migrated to National League teams, including stars like Juan Soto, Roki Sasaki, and Corbin Burnes. This shift in talent distribution creates an opportunity for Boston to capitalize on a relatively weaker American League by bolstering key areas of their roster. With Anthony Santander recently joining the Blue Jays, Boston may feel increased urgency to respond with impactful moves of their own.
Looking Ahead: Pivotal Decisions for Boston
The Red Sox’s reluctance to commit to Tanner Scott underscores their cautious approach, but the front office must now pivot effectively to finish their offseason on a strong note. Securing Estévez or Yates, adding an impactful infielder like Bregman, and potentially exploring additional trades or free-agent signings could transform Boston into a formidable force.
To emerge as a serious contender, the Red Sox must blend calculated risk-taking with aggressive decision-making. By making the right moves in the coming weeks, they can turn this offseason into the foundation for success in 2025 and beyond.
